Transcript page 45-4 with numbered lines, recording the clerk asking how the jury finds each defendant and the foreman answering Guilty or Not guilty
Open the full imageJPG, 1100 × 1412 px, 0.3 MB

Transcript: the verdict, 4:30 p.m., July 11, 1979 (United States v. Winter)

The digitized transcript of the taking of the jury's verdict in United States v. Howard T. Winter et al. The page shown records the foreman's answers on count one for six defendants and the first answer on count two, "Guilty" for Howard Winter.

Date
1979-07-11
Kind
case-file
Retrieved
2026-10-12
NAID
192810459
Docket
Cr. No. 79-00042, United States District Court, District of Massachusetts
Rights
A transcript filed in United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts, held by the National Archives at Boston (Record Group 21). A federal court record, public domain under 17 U.S.C. § 105; the catalog marks this item's use "Unrestricted." The parent series is marked "Restricted - Possibly" because it also holds newspaper clippings; no clipping is used here. The stored image is a page of the transcript.

A digitized transcript of 31 images. The cover (stored here) reads “Cr. No. 79-00042,” “Mazzone, D. J. and a Jury,” “United States of America v. Howard T. Winter, et ali,” “Verdict,” “Courtroom No. 3, Federal Building, Boston, Massachusetts, 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, July 11, 1979.” A receipt stamp of the clerk’s office reads “JUL 15” with the year only partly legible.

Transcript page 45-4, shown above, was read in full. On count one the clerk asks how the jury finds Melvin Goldenberg, Elliot Paul Price, Sidney Tildsley, Charles Demetri and James Demetri, and the foreman answers “Guilty” for each. For Norman Mercier the foreman answers “Not guilty.” The clerk then asks: “On count two, how do you find the defendant, Howard Winter?” The foreman answers “Guilty.” The page ends as the clerk begins to ask about James Martorano on count two.

The verdicts on the remaining counts and defendants are on the later pages, which have not been read for this archive. The page shown does not say what count one or count two charged. The First Circuit’s opinions describe the convictions it affirmed and the two it reversed.

itemUnited States v. Howard T. Winter et al., criminal case file 79-CR-00042-MA (D. Mass.)National Archives description of the District of Massachusetts case file in the horse-race fixing prosecution: a 52-count indictment against 21 defendants, with trial transcripts and papers on the First Circuit appeal.itemUnited States v. Martorano, 663 F.2d 1113 (1st Cir. 1981): new-trial motions in the race-fixing caseFirst Circuit opinion of October 30, 1981 affirming the denial of new-trial motions by Howard T. Winter, James Martorano and four codefendants, based on FBI reports and grand jury testimony of the Government's chief witness, Anthony Ciulla, that had not been disclosed before trial.itemTranscript excerpt: opening statement and testimony of Anthony Ciulla, fourth day of trial, May 8, 1979 (United States v. Winter)The cover of a digitized trial transcript in United States v. Howard Winter et al.: the Government's opening statement and the testimony of Anthony Ciulla on the fourth day of the jury trial, May 8, 1979.itemTranscript: fifth day of trial, May 9, 1979 (United States v. Winter)The cover of the digitized transcript of the fifth day of the jury trial in United States v. Howard T. Winter et al., Courtroom No. 4, Boston, May 9, 1979.itemTranscript: thirtieth day of trial, June 21, 1979 (United States v. Winter)The cover of the digitized transcript of the thirtieth day of the jury trial in United States v. Howard T. Winter et al., Courtroom No. 3, Boston, June 21, 1979.itemTranscript: Judge Mazzone's charge to the jury, July 6, 1979 (United States v. Winter)The cover of the digitized transcript of the judge's charge to the jury in United States v. Howard T. Winter et al., Courtroom No. 3, Post Office & Courthouse, Boston, July 6, 1979.itemUnited States v. Winter, 663 F.2d 1120 (1st Cir. 1981)First Circuit opinion of October 30, 1981 on a 42-count RICO prosecution of a horse-race-fixing enterprise that bribed jockeys at East Coast tracks from 1973 to 1975. Four convictions were affirmed and two reversed.